Books Behind Bars: Censorship, The Path To A Utopia.

I
will begin with two censored novels that share the same theme of racism and are
witness to the sword of censorship being held to their chins. One of them is Mark
Twain’s The Adventures Of Huckleberry Finn and the other is Harper Lee’s
To Kill A Mockingbird. They are banned in Massachusetts and Mississippi
respectively for the themes of racism and the use of the n-word. The n-word
appears over 200 times in The Adventures Of Huckleberry Finn, very
diligent readers have shared. Now, what I cannot comprehend is this, and you
are free to disagree. While both novels do blatantly use racist words that are
controversial and offensive today, they are a realistic reflection of the 19th
century. An age in which such language was normalized and humans fought to rise
above other humans in the most brutal ways owing to the pigment of their skin.
Today, we live in a world where we have the sense and opportunities to understand
the depth of the word preventing us from using them. These novels, to me, are a
repository of history. I know for a fact that these two books taught me very effectively
about the need for the Black Lives Matter movement today and allowed me a peak
into an era where racism was rampant. To me, the messages underpinning these
novels are not superficial but strong. That is, that skin and divisions based
on skin are constructions that can be shed away when you take a step away from the
society that builds them. That is what Huck does, in how his attachment to Jim
proves to be strong enough for him to see him as a friend by the
end of the novel. Similarly, Mockingbird sheds light on the injustice against a
Black man wrongfully charged, and how there are White people such as Atticus
who go beyond the common ideology and see past skin. The world then, is not
just black and white but makes space for a spectrum of grey in between. So how
then, or why then do these novels deserve to be held at the end of an
eraser? To me it’s almost as if certain groups of people want to censor what
they don’t like in a futile attempt to create a utopia. Imagine, years from
now, there would be a generation who could have peaked into a brutal past like
I did but will not be able to do so. History is important because we can
attempt to not repeat it. But if history is erased, what then?Another reason for censorship is religious blasphemy. Cogwheel Buddha by Tennyson Perera holds the title for being the first novel banned in Sri Lanka for this reason as was Salman Rushdie’s The Satanic Verses, reasoning blasphemy against Buddhism and Islam respectively. Let’s also pan our gaze towards Ray Bradbury’s Fahrenheit 451 for a moment. A world in which firefighters are equipped with the task of burning books rather than saving people because books are knowledge and knowledge is liberation. I find it very amusing that this novel itself is banned in some places because of its use of profanity. Other interesting texts I found were banned include Paulo Freire’s Pedagogy Of The Oppressed, which is banned in Arizona USA, South Africa and certain Latin American countries. Interestingly, I haven’t been able to pinpoint the exact reasons for this except South Africa’s accusation of it being a tool of ‘’ideological weaponry’’. Well, some people sitting on their banking method must be sleeping soundly each night. Similarly George Orwell’s Animal Farm is banned in China for fear of children treating animals as equals owing to the anthropomorphic qualities attributed to them in the novel. Oh metaphors. I do shed a tear for your untimely end.
So, in my view, the major problem with this form of
censorship is not merely the signs to the end of freedom of speech but also a
sort of disinterest by people in power to truly engage with these texts and
comprehend the layers beneath what they see. Literature is supposed to make you
think, maybe squirm a bit in uncomfortableness to make the gears in your
head turn. The reasons for some of these censorships are ridiculous to me but
who am I to judge. I do believe it’s important to have all sorts of ideas and
thoughts available to us or we will all think the same and well, become a monotonous
society living in a utopia. I think I shared my dilemmas with you as I come to
an end. Well then. Are you a firefighter in a utopia or will you question the
common narrative?



"The Kite Runner" and "To Kill a Mockingbird" are two of my favorite novels from the ones you have mentioned and it's really sad that some people are not given access to these books. I learned so much from them and it's quite ironic that people think banning books that simply narrate our reality could solve problems like racism or extremism.
ReplyDelete- Sasha
I completely agree and I wish people who have no access to these novels would be able to read them at some point because like you and I, it's not just a story, but a learning experience! Thanks for commenting
Delete-Nipuni
Whoa.. I had no idea some of these books were banned in some countries! And some for the most silliest reasons! Censoring books which requires the readers to step out of their ignorant bubbles, rack their brains and think and question, in my opinion, is a way of exercising dominance and control over that society. Those in power wouldn't want us to see the reality, get all riled up and disrupt the order that they worked so hard to maintain now would they? :)
ReplyDeleteYes, I'm sure that's the masterplan but we are in on it now >:) ! I know! I had to re-read some of the reasons for banning these books and it made no sense to me! A bit of controversy in my opinion stirs the pot a bit and can create great discourse like you rightly pointed out! Thanks for commenting and welcome to reality!
Delete-Nipuni
I remember what a strong impact learning Freire had on all of us last year, and to think that it has been censored in certain countries? What even!!! And I can't even begin to understand why Rowling has been censored either- I cannot imagine a world without Harry Potter haha. Literature is supposed to enrich our lives and widen our perspective about the world, like you have pointed out, but I guess that's the exact opposite of what those in power want for us... gosh I cannot BELIEVE that some of the books that have been censored have been censored for the reasons that they have been censored.
ReplyDeleteOh yes Harry Potter is banned in some countries because it apparently encourages dark magic! I remember when the fifth book came out, I was watching CNN and they showed videos of people burning the books in some countries. And what you said about Freire is also shocking and I find it amusing that it's censored for ''inciting possible coups''. They say that if something instigates a strong reaction like Freire's book does, you're doing or exposing something right and hit a nerve!
DeleteAlmost forgot, thank you for commenting Theru!
Delete